Richard Berg Skrevet 7 minutter siden Skrevet 7 minutter siden I'm writing to point out some problems I discovered with the metadata, shown in search pages I used at digitalarkivet.no, derived from church book birth record of my great granduncle's daughter, Alice Pauline Johnson (Johansen). Here's the original scanned church book page from Grønland Parish Office Church Books, AV/SAO-A-10848/F/Fa/L0007: Parish register no. 7, 1878-1888, page 47: https://media.digitalarkivet.no/view/5790/52 Here's the metadata (search) page for Alice: https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496382 Note that the mother's name on the church record is Caroline Sofie Larsen - this is correct. It's beneath the father's name. On the metadata page, the mother's name is Pauline Josephine Augusta Johannesensdatter. This is wrong - it was taken in error from the line above the father's name. The same transcription error appears for almost all of the boy's and girl's parents on this particular page of the church book. Summary of "mother’s-name-from-the-line-above" errors compared with the church book page: Bernhard - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496349 - right Lars - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496352 - wrong Victor - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496355 - wrong Fritjof- https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496358 - wrong Oscar - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496361 - right Trygve - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496364 - right Christian - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496367 - right Alfred - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496370 - wrong Svante - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496373 - right --------------- Thora - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496376 - right Ovidia - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496379 - wrong Alice - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496382 - wrong Mathilda - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496385 - wrong Jenny - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496388 - wrong Margit - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496391 - (uagte) both parents wrong Beata - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496394 - wrong Inga - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496397 - wrong Magda - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496400 - wrong Signora- https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496370 - wrong Sadly, the problem is not confined to this one church book page. Here's one sample from the previous page: https://media.digitalarkivet.no/view/5790/51 Sigrid - https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/view/255/pd00000032496379 - wrong Comments: I can't comprehend how difficult the task is to construct all the millions of metadata records. It's a completely worthwhile effort and one which genealogists everywhere I'm sure are grateful for having. Unfortunately, professional genealogists and family genealogists like me, who rely on your sites to search for family relationships, get totally misdirected by errors like these. Someone at AMF who transcribed the metadata for this church book was either poorly trained or poorly supervised, or just tired. The significant result is that probably hundreds of individual's family trees are wrong. Because of similar tools available on AMF, the errors are propagated to other genealogists who blindly take the accuracy of the information without question or without other confirmation. This is a disservice to families throughout the world. I wish I had the time to be a proofreader for digitalarkivet.no, but I don't, and it's not my calling. To be completely fair, in five years of deep-dive family genealogy, this is the first instance I've encountered of this kind of error. Thus, I believe errors like these reflect only a very, very tiny percentage of the metadata. And I am extremely grateful for the availability of the free digitized records of all kinds in the archives at digitalarkivet.no. Thank you. Richard A Berg Dryden, NY USA
Recommended Posts
Logg inn for å kommentere
Du vil kunne skrive en kommentar etter at du logger inn
Logg inn nå